New York City. As much as people are drawn to it – residents and tourists alike – they also need an escape. The non-stop hustle and bustle can be overwhelming unless tempered by purer pleasures. Simple things like grassy fields, hiking trails and apples plucked from the tree.
Enter the Catskill Mountains. Some 220km northwest of the city, under three hours by car, Catskill Park, spread across four counties, is home to a 116,000ha parcel of state-protected Forest Preserve. You can trek through endless oak and fir woods to towering waterfalls, like the two-tiered, 79m Kaaterskill Falls near the town of Hunter; go fly fishing for rainbow trout and smallmouth bass in the Delaware River; and pick peaches and sip fresh cider at the surrounding bountiful farms and orchards. For much of the 20th century, the escape New Yorkers sought was found here.
In fact, one of the country’s earliest resorts was Catskill Mountain House, which opened in 1824, and was visited by the city’s elite as well as three United States presidents – Ulysses S Grant, Chester A Arthur and Teddy Roosevelt. Hundreds of sprawling resorts followed, each offering grand amenities from Olympic-sized pools and golf clubs to headlining comedians and big-band entertainment. The area’s glory days arrived in the 1920s and lasted through the ’60s, when much of New York City’s Jewish community vacationed there, earning it nicknames like the Borscht Belt and the Jewish Alps.
But by the 1970s, the area had fallen out of favour, the allure of vacationing further afield too strong to resist as air travel became cheaper and more prevalent. After all, why drive upstate when you could jet off to Europe or a tropical island?
Now, though, things are coming full circle. Both city folk and international travellers are rediscovering the Catskills’ simple and accessible pleasures and beauty, and there’s a new generation of resorts catering to the returning crowds. What’s notable, however, about these fresh hotel arrivals is that they’re quite different to their forebears, combining that rustic charm of old with a decidedly more urbane sensibility.
“I’ve been very surprised at how quickly it’s caught on and how many people are coming to the Catskills for the first time,” says Marc Chodock, co-founder and managing partner of Scribner’s Catskill Lodge, which opened in one of the abandoned inns in Hunter, in the northeast region, in late 2016. When he and his previous partner took over the defunct space, they remodelled it with a modern mountain aesthetic that balances sophistication and rusticity. Each of the 38 rooms features custom furniture and vintage rugs; some have potbelly stoves and sleeping lofts, and many have small decks where you can enjoy a seat in an Adirondack chair and take in the fresh air and view of Hunter Mountain, the most popular ski resort in the area, which lies just across the street.
“There’s sunbathing in the summer, leaf peeping in the fall, it’s great to go skiing or snowshoeing
in the winter, and biking in the spring”
Chodock himself, a management consultant and private equity investor before opening Scribner’s, was charmed by the area when he first started exploring it. “What I love about the Catskills is that it’s a year-round destination. There’s sunbathing in the summer, leaf peeping in the fall; it’s great to go skiing or snowshoeing in the winter and biking in the spring.”
And yet for all that the area had to offer, he also noticed there weren’t any particularly stylish places to stay. “You could see the demand far exceeded what was offered,” says Chodock, who now splits his time between the city and Hunter, catering to a broad base of guests, from groups of friends to young families looking for a fun and relaxing getaway.
Sims Foster, who was born and raised in the Catskills and worked in hospitality out of Manhattan for 20 years, saw the same opportunity to connect with people who were curious to explore the area. Since 2014, he and his wife, Kirsten Harlow Foster, have opened not one, but four inns across the towns of Livingston Manor, North Branch and Callicoon in the southwestern pocket of the Catskills. “The visitors finding us, and the area, have a real sense of adventure,” he says. “We rarely get the pragmatic ‘I need a place to stay’ kind of guest. They want an experience.”
As such, each of their four properties leans into a different vibe to speak to different travellers. The four-year-old Arnold House attracts a younger, lively crowd with its pool table, jukebox and local bands playing in the barn on summer nights. Quiet and romantic, the North Branch Inn offers classic Americana, right down to the working two-lane bowling alley located in the open kitchen. Meanwhile, Nine River Road, which debuted in 2016, backs up to the Delaware River so kayaking, canoeing and simply watching the water is great for groups seeking fun and action. And at the polished new DeBruce, the focus is equally on the outdoors and an unforgettable culinary experience. It is located on 240 hectares with hiking trails, fly fishing and welcoming lounge chairs to sit in and read a book. You could stay and never leave the property, especially since days are capped off with a nine-course dinner created by executive chef Aksel Theilkuhl using ingredients primarily foraged on the grounds.
Clearly the resorts of today differ from those of yesteryear. Not only are they smaller and more intimate, but they channel the creativity of their owners and are in tune with visitors’ desire to escape to the country without leaving behind little luxuries.
When Eliza Clark and Tim Trojian started looking to move to the Catskills from Toronto, they had very specific requirements. “The main thing we wanted was a true connection to a place where we could be inspired daily by the beauty of our surroundings,” Clark reflects. “We wanted to create a life where we could combine our skills and work together.” So Foxfire Mountain House was born.
“The main thing we wanted was a true connection to a place where we could be inspired daily by the beauty of our surroundings”
Located in Mount Tremper, in the shadows of Slide Mountain, the tallest peak in the Catskills, Foxfire brings a bohemian flair to its four hectares, as opposed to Scribner’s smart design and the Foster properties’ edgy rusticity. The couple spent two years renovating the hundred-year-old inn largely themselves, appointing the 11 guest rooms, three-bedroom cottage and all the common areas with worldly touches like Moroccan tiles and silk sari curtains from India, juxtaposing them with natural elements from the region – everything from butterfly collections to antlers and branches. Clark, a former television producer, focuses on design and Trojian, a chef, runs the kitchen and just-opened outdoor fire pit, where the couple envision guests enjoying fare like oysters and spicy sausages, while hanging out and listening to music on the grounds.